Brand Logo

I Rented a FARO Laser Tracker. The $4,200 Mistake Wasn't the Machine—It Was My Checklist.

In September 2023, our fabrication team flagged something that had been drifting quietly for months: dimensional inconsistencies on a run of large weldments. Not catastrophic. But consistent enough that the customer's incoming inspection started rejecting units. Two in a row, then a third.

I handle metrology procurement and calibration scheduling for our shop—seven years now. I've personally made (and documented) 11 significant purchasing mistakes totaling roughly $14,600 in wasted budget or rework. I keep the checklist so nobody else repeats them. This story is about mistake number eight, and the tool configuration that finally fixed it.

The Setup: Digital Micrometers Weren't Cutting It

Before you ask—yes, we already had digital micrometers. Decent ones. We used them for shaft diameters, plate thickness, that kind of thing. For weldments pushing 3 meters across, a handheld micrometer is the wrong tool. You can measure feature-by-feature, but you're stacking operator error on top of fixturing error on top of thermal expansion. And on a Friday afternoon shift, nobody's doing trig to correct for ambient temperature.

So we were doing the classic thing: stretch a tape, use a laser distance meter for a ballpark, then hope the CMM room wasn't backed up. It worked until it didn't. The rework on three rejected weldments came to about $4,200—cutting, re-fixturing, re-welding, re-inspection. Plus a two-week production delay that pushed two other jobs.

Bottom line: we needed a portable measurement solution for large parts, and we needed it before Q4 volume hit.

The Decision: Rent a FARO Laser Tracker

I'd used a FARO laser tracker at a previous shop, so it was the first thing I thought of. For large-volume measurement—3 to 30 meters—a laser tracker is the right category of tool. The mechanics are straightforward: the tracker follows a retroreflector, and you get point coordinates in a spherical coordinate system.

The risk calculus went like this. Buying a new tracker system is a serious capital expense—we're talking five figures before you add targets, software, and training. Renting a FARO laser tracker rental for a two-month pilot was roughly $3,800. The upside was proving the workflow before committing capital. The risk was that the rental unit would sit idle while we figured out how to integrate it.

I kept asking myself: is $3,800 cheaper than buying the wrong thing? Yes. That one was easy. What wasn't easy was admitting, six weeks in, that the tracker wasn't the whole answer.

The Turn: When the Laser Can't See

Here's what the brochure doesn't tell you about laser trackers: they need line of sight. Obvious in hindsight. Less obvious when you're trying to measure the inside of a weldment assembly where a gusset plate blocks the beam. We had a support bracket configuration that required hitting points in a recessed area. The tracker was blind to about 15% of the critical features.

Never expected the bottleneck to be geometry. Turns out the tracker was excellent at the open-frame measurements—flatness, hole positions on the exterior, overall envelope. But for the tucked-in features, we were back to a mirror and a flashlight, which is not a measurement strategy I'd recommend to anyone.

That's when our calibration tech mentioned the FARO Arm CMM sitting in the corner of the metrology lab. A portable articulated arm with a hard probe. Lower volume range, but it doesn't care about line of sight. You just reach in and touch points.

Part of me was annoyed I hadn't thought of it first. Another part was relieved we already had one on the floor. We spent the next two weeks cross-referencing: tracker for the global envelope, arm for the recessed features. The mismatch between the two datasets dropped from about 0.8 mm to under 0.15 mm.

The Side Quest: Electrical Maintenance Tools and a Thermal Camera

While the rental was running, our maintenance team flagged two separate needs that got tangled into the same purchase conversation. First, they needed a better multimeter for the electricians—specifically, they were asking what is the best Fluke multimeter for electricians who work on 480V motor controls. Second, they wanted a thermal camera to catch overheating connections before they failed.

On the multimeter: I'm not going to pretend I have a definitive answer. The Fluke 87V is what our senior electrician uses and swears by—True RMS, CAT IV rating, the works. But one of the younger techs prefers the 117 for general troubleshooting because it's simpler to navigate. The honest answer is that "best" depends on whether you're doing industrial control work or general electrical. If you're mostly on motor drives and PLCs, the 87V's low-pass filter matters. If you're doing basic voltage/continuity checks, the 117 is fine and cheaper.

The thermal camera was trickier. We looked at a few options, and I almost pulled the trigger on a one gen 3 thermal camera bundle that looked good on paper. At the last minute, our reliability engineer pointed out that the resolution wasn't going to cut it for catching small hot spots on densely packed terminal blocks. We ended up with a higher-resolution unit—more money, but it actually told us something useful. The first scan found a loose lug on a disconnect that was running 22°C hotter than its neighbors. That alone justified the purchase.

The lesson there: the "affordable" option is only affordable if it answers the question you're actually asking. Otherwise it's a $600 paperweight.

The Result: A Two-Tool Workflow, Not a One-Tool Solution

After the rental period ended, we didn't buy a laser tracker. Not because it wasn't good—it was excellent for what it did. But the honest math said we needed the tracker for maybe 20% of our jobs. For the rest, the Arm CMM plus a set of digital micrometers handled most of it.

What we did instead: kept the arm as our primary portable measurement tool, and established a rental protocol for the tracker when we get large-frame jobs that need it. The rental vendor we used offers a monthly rate that works out to roughly $1,900 for a standard tracker package (based on our quotes from September 2023; verify current pricing directly with the vendor).

We also formalized a pre-purchase checklist. Since then, we've run 47 measurement tool evaluations through it. We've avoided at least three purchases that looked reasonable but would have duplicated existing capability or missed the actual measurement range we needed.

The Reckoning: What I'd Tell the 2022 Version of Myself

If you're looking at a FARO laser tracker rental or trying to decide between a tracker and an arm CMM, here's the short version of what I learned:

A laser tracker is the right tool when: you're measuring large open structures (3m+), you need high accuracy over long distances, and your critical features are accessible by line of sight. It's fast, it's precise, and the software handles large point clouds well.

An arm CMM is the right tool when: you need to measure recessed or obscured features, your parts are smaller (under 2–3m typically), and you want something you can move around the shop floor without a dedicated setup. It's slower on big jobs, but it doesn't care about what's in the way.

The mistake wasn't renting the tracker. The mistake was assuming one tool would cover every measurement scenario we had. If I'd run the recessed-feature question through the checklist before the rental started, I would've saved about $1,800 in idle rental time and a week of head-scratching.

I have mixed feelings about that outcome. On one hand, the rental gave us confidence that the tracker workflow works for our large-frame jobs, which is valuable. On the other, I could've gotten there faster with a more honest look at our feature accessibility. That's the checklist's job now—to force the obvious questions before the purchase order gets signed.

Prices cited are from September 2023 quotes; verify current rates with your vendor. Measurement tolerances vary by environment and operator technique—run a gauge R&R study before trusting any portable system on critical features.

Share on WhatsApp

Leave a Reply